The US Federal Housing Finance Agency’s (FHFA) recent decision to revamp federal rules on mortgage fees has stirred controversy, with concerns raised about the impact on high-credit buyers. The new rules will offer discounted rates for homebuyers with riskier credit backgrounds, while forcing higher-credit homebuyers to pay higher costs, which has been met with criticism from the mortgage industry. In this article, we will delve into the FHFA’s changes and explore the potential effects on the housing market and mortgage industry.

What are the Changes to Mortgage Fees?

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, government-sponsored enterprises that buy and resell loans, will adjust fees known as loan-level price adjustments (LLPAs) from May 1, 2023. The changes will affect mortgages originating from private banks nationwide, from Wells Fargo to JPMorgan Chase. The fees are upfront fees that factor in borrowers’ credit scores and down payments and are typically converted into percentage points that alter the buyer’s mortgage rate. Under the revised pricing structure, high-credit buyers with scores ranging from 680 to above 780 will face a spike in their mortgage costs, with applicants who place 15% to 20% down payments experiencing the biggest increase in fees. Meanwhile, buyers with credit scores of 679 or lower will have their fees slashed, resulting in more favorable mortgage rates.

The FHFA-ordered overhaul of LLPAs affects purchase loans, limited cash-out refinances, and cash-out refinance loans. The revamped pricing matrix also includes the controversial addition of a new charge for buyers with debt-to-income ratios above 40%. However, FHFA announced last month it would delay the rollout of the debt-to-income fee until at least August 1, to “ensure a level playing field for all lenders to have sufficient time to deploy the fee.”

The FHFA’s Aim to Boost Affordability

The changes to mortgage fees are the latest of several moves by the FHFA aimed at boosting affordability for “mission borrowers,” defined as first-time buyers, low-income borrowers, and applicants from underserved communities. Last year, the FHFA eliminated upfront fees for first-time buyers who are at or below 100% of their area’s median income, or 120% in areas that are identified as “high cost.” The agency also raised upfront fees on second homes and some larger mortgage loans.

The FHFA’s intention to boost affordability for those in need is admirable, but the question is whether the new pricing structure will achieve this goal. Critics suggest that the changes may add more pressure on a core segment of buyers in a housing market already in the midst of a major downturn, and high-credit buyers may be hit harder than expected.

Impact on High-Credit Buyers

High-credit buyers may be the hardest hit by the new pricing structure. They may face pricier monthly mortgage payments, which could come as an unwelcome surprise for those who worked for years to build their credit. The new pricing structure will be a challenge to explain to high-credit buyers, who may find it hard to accept that their credit quality is now a disadvantage. However, the FHFA official responded to concerns by saying that the agency was “tasked with ensuring [Fannie and Freddie] fulfill their role in any market condition,” adding that shifts in long-term mortgage rates are a far bigger factor in determining finance conditions in the US housing market.

The Mortgage Industry’s Reaction

The mortgage industry has been quick to criticize the changes to mortgage fees. The new pricing structure is a significant cross-subsidy pricing change that impacts high-credit buyers negatively, according to David Stevens, the former CEO of the Mortgage Bankers Association. The changes could further complicate the strenuous mortgage application process and add more pressure on a core segment of buyers in a housing market already in the midst of a major downturn. The timing of the changes has also been called into question, as they come at a time when home purchases are impacted by rate increases over the past year, making the situation less than ideal.

Moreover, the mortgage industry is concerned that the changes may complicate the mortgage application process, as lenders will have to adjust their pricing matrix to accommodate the new fees. Lenders will also have to reconfigure their systems to determine the fees charged to borrowers accurately. These changes could result in more work for lenders, which may ultimately increase the cost of originating a mortgage.

Potential Effects on the Housing Market

The impact of the changes to mortgage fees on the housing market is yet to be seen. However, there are concerns that the changes may worsen the already-strained housing market. The average 30-year mortgage rate is hovering at 6.27% as of last week, up from about 5% one year ago and more than twice as high as it was two years ago, according to Freddie Mac data. With higher mortgage rates, the cost of borrowing becomes more expensive, making it harder for borrowers to afford a mortgage.

The changes to mortgage fees may also exacerbate the current housing affordability crisis, as home prices continue to soar, and low- and middle-income households struggle to buy a home. While the FHFA’s intention to boost affordability for mission borrowers is commendable, the new pricing structure may have the opposite effect, making it harder for some buyers to afford a home.

The End Result

The FHFA’s decision to revamp federal rules on mortgage fees has stirred controversy, with concerns raised about the impact on high-credit buyers. The new pricing structure will offer discounted rates for homebuyers with riskier credit backgrounds, while forcing higher-credit homebuyers to foot the bill. While the FHFA’s intention to boost affordability for mission borrowers is commendable, the new pricing structure may have unintended consequences, making it harder for some buyers to afford a home.

If you need any help regarding these issues Corridor Consulting would love to help, please schedule a discovery session here, and we’ll be able to address these issues and much more! We’re looking forward to opening many more doors for you!

If you found this article helpful and enjoyed it please share it with others and join our newsletter below

This article is not professional tax or legal advice for your specific circumstances. Consult with your professional adviser to better understand how these items may impact you, or how they’ve changed